Jump to content
WI BIMMERS - Wisconsin's BMW Community

Migrating The Family truckster E38 to ?


RobZR

Recommended Posts

Looking to replace the trusty E38 '01 740IL for a more modern gadget chariot for the wife.

She want's something smaller yet still filled with gadgets in $10k range.

Been looking at E60's, E53 X5's, E90's

I Have wrenched on all my cars even doing the guides/vanos on the M62TU, but the tech overload scares me.

What's the pitfalls of the E60/N54 combo?  looks like fun!!

How is the reliability of X-drive models?

RobZR

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I have been reading up on the N54 quirks and it seems to be M54 issues + Injectors, turbos, wastegates, etc. these all seem to go by 100k mi. and many get replaced under extended warranty/recall. Finding the right one is going to be the key. The "right seller" will have pored a ton of money into all these repairs and want out.

The E60 question is harder to answer. the common advised solution is "buy an extended warranty" I would expect the common brakes, bushings and ball joints, but what the ##$@ is a $1500 hydraulically assisted sway bar. On top of EDC shocks. 

The E60 community is nothing like the E34 & E38 groups even though the cars are getting old, not many people wrenching on these like the older cars.

Found the  "So You Just Bought an E60"  write-up, and it's making me grey just looking at it.

 I see a lot of seat time in front of the PC coding the car. not just wrenching.

Anyone got hands on experience in the E60 world?  What falls apart in the Rust Belt beyond the usual list?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It sounds like you are looking for someone to say "it's not as complicated as you think" which is true.  You just need to invest in new tools and broaden your skill set to include computers for some items.  Also, yes, cars that were expensive new still have expensive parts on them that may be expensive when replaced 10+ years later.  New BMW's don't really rust either because of the materials used.  They corrode if they aren't washed regularly but that only makes disassembly difficult.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, RobZR said:

Actually, I'm looking for the opposite, someone to tell me "forget it, stick with what you know (E3X cars). Why would you want put yourself through all that" . 

Yet, as long as she is driving a Bimmer, she is more understanding to my addiction and the rest of the fleet.  Happy wife, bimmer life.

 

We're saying the same thing just different ways.  So, buy the damn car and spread your horizons.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

On 3/15/2017 at 11:12 PM, RobZR said:

 

I have been reading up on the N54 quirks and it seems to be M54 issues + Injectors, turbos, wastegates, etc. these all seem to go by 100k mi. and many get replaced under extended warranty/recall. Finding the right one is going to be the key. The "right seller" will have pored a ton of money into all these repairs and want out.

The E60 question is harder to answer. the common advised solution is "buy an extended warranty" I would expect the common brakes, bushings and ball joints, but what the ##$@ is a $1500 hydraulically assisted sway bar. On top of EDC shocks. 

 

It it is better to get the higher mileage car that has already had all the major repairs done then the low mileage one that is going to need them. As long as the body isn't rusting and showing signs of wear.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's the only way to go. Buy them @130k with good service history and all the normal stuff done.  You get it for about $3k less and save $2k getting it all sorted. All for another 40k on the clock. I have followed this recipe for a decade.   The rust problem is solved by not buying local.

Now off to find the right car.  No big hurry.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 10 months later...

Found a nice '10 535i Msport with full dealer service records and got some questions before I buy it. Looking for group input.

Car has 120K mi and full dealer service. 16k OCI, no trans fluid service,  brakes done, VC replaced, OFH leak fixed,  Expansion tank done,  Fuel and ignition system replaced, O2's replaced.

No record of repairs to water pump, turbos, or suspension, and has a light oil pan leak.

 

Should I use the needed service to negotiate a better deal or cut and run?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, RobZR said:

I figure the oil pan gasket is a low $, high DIY scale item compared to other big ticket items on these.

The turbos and trans would be my big worries with the factory OCI's

The turbo isn't an issue on these.  Even when neglected the single turbo on the n55 didn't develop the same issues as the twins on the n54.  Trans isn't an issue either.  There was a concern with the trans not staying in sport mode but it's easily fixed if you know how to solder.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, RobZR said:

I thought E60's only got the N54. never seen one with a N55.

You're right!  My fault, I was thinking it was an F10 not an E60.  In that case, your turbo's may be an issue at some point.  You could try and negotiate it but if they're not making any noise I don't know how many lot's are going to really make up the cost to repair in the sale price.  My comments about the trans remain the same.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I hate cars in the mileage range you are looking at here. It is simply statistics that 120k miles on a 535 without any major stuff being broken/fixed yet is a significant risk for bigger repairs coming soon. Anything to the contrary said by anyone who talks about their personal experience with a small handful of cars is anecdotal at best. Many cars simply are at risk to start needing some bigger ticket items between 100-125k miles, give or take. To me it's worse with these later model vehicles because there is just more to go wrong over time as a result of ever-increasing features and tech. There is a reason that extended manufacturer warranties run out between 72k and 100k. The price on that car has got to be just absolutely dirt cheap and I still wouldn't touch it. 

And that's saying a lot coming from a guy who is about to spend $1600 to "proactively" replace rod bearings because he drives a car that is known to eat its own $15k engine. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The 80-120k mi car market is the no go zone in my book.  The premium on cars under 100Kmi is almost 50% over those above 120k, and for that you get to repair all the parts that wear our from the 1st 100k of use.  The car in question has already incurred ~$8k of dealer service in the zone, yet by my estimate it still needs  ~$3k(dealer $) of immediate needs and additional $4k(dealer $) of proactive/ risk repairs.

  DIY allows me to bring all that down to a manageable $1500 part cost , rest is sweat equity. 

As most people would say " you have to be insane to own these out of warranty".  With DIY and group of friends stricken with the same disease we can make this work for ~25% of the MSRP

 

msport.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.